Childbirth is a unique and transformative experience, and everyone’s journey is different. As the due date approaches, those expecting may consider various methods to help initiate labour. One such method is a membrane sweep, also known as stretch and sweep. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the experiences of those who have undergone membrane sweeps, understand the procedure, its effectiveness, and potential risks. Midwives play a crucial role in supporting and empowering women throughout their labour process. So, let’s dive in and discover how this drug-free technique may help those who are past their due date.
What is Membrane Sweeping?
A membrane sweep is a relatively simple procedure that can be performed during a routine antenatal visit. It is usually offered at their 40-week and 41-week appointments during their first pregnancy or at their 41-week appointment if they have had a baby before. However, it is important to note that they have the right to decline a membrane sweep if they choose to.
Membrane sweeping is a mechanical method of labour induction that can be performed without the use of medications or pharmaceuticals. It involves a midwife/care provider inserting one or two gloved fingers into the vagina and through the cervix. They then use a continuous, circular, sweeping motion to separate the bag of water surrounding the baby from the lower part of the uterus. The primary purpose of membrane sweeping is to encourage the onset of labour. By stimulating the cervix, the hope is that the release of hormones and prostaglandins will trigger contractions and initiate the birthing process. This procedure is often offered to women approaching their due date as an alternative to hospital induction of labour.
Why is Membrane Sweeping Used for Inducing Labour?
The effectiveness of membrane sweeping as a method of labour induction remains a topic of debate. While some studies suggest that it may accelerate the onset of labour, the overall evidence is inconclusive. A Cochrane review found that, on average, eight women need to undergo a membrane sweep for one woman to go into labour without requiring additional induction methods. However, it is important to note that this figure assumes all women would choose induction, which may not be the case for everyone.
As with any medical procedure, membrane sweeping is not without controversies. One of the main concerns is the lack of informed consent and thorough discussion between healthcare providers and women. In some cases, membrane sweeping has been suggested without proper explanation or consideration of the woman’s preferences. Additionally, there are potential risks and discomfort associated with the procedure, including slight bleeding, sporadic contractions, and the possibility of infection.
What to Expect After a Membrane Sweep
After a membrane sweep, it is common to experience some spotting and mild cramping. These symptoms are usually temporary and subside within a few days. However, if you experience excessive bleeding or severe pain, it is important to contact your healthcare provider or go to the hospital for evaluation.
Labour may start within the next couple of days following a membrane sweep. However, it is essential to remember that every woman’s labour journey is unique, and the timing of labour onset can vary. Patience and open communication with your healthcare provider are crucial during this time.
Membrane sweeping is generally considered safe in uncomplicated pregnancies. However, as with any medical procedure, there are potential risks and considerations that need to be taken into account. It is crucial for healthcare providers to assess whether membrane sweeping is suitable for each individual and to weigh the benefits against the possible risks.
Minor risks associated with membrane sweeping include mild discomfort during the procedure, minor vaginal bleeding, and irregular contractions. These side effects are typically temporary and resolve on their own. However, there are certain circumstances in which membrane sweeping may not be recommended or may be contraindicated.
Effectiveness of Membrane Sweeping
The effectiveness of membrane sweeping in inducing labour varies from woman to woman. Studies have shown that approximately 90% of women who undergo a membrane sweep deliver by 41 weeks, compared to 75% of women who do not have the procedure. The success rate may be higher when the membrane sweep is performed after the due date.
It is important to note that membrane sweeping is not as effective as other methods of labour induction, such as the use of Pitocin. It is typically recommended when there is no pressing medical reason for immediate induction. However, every woman’s body responds differently, and the success of membrane sweeping can vary.
Alternatives to Membrane Sweeping for Inducing Labour
Biomechanics and Positional Changes
Biomechanics, the study of biology and the mechanisms of movement, plays a significant role in childbirth. Positional changes and biomechanical principles can help babies rotate and turn to navigate the pelvis. Evidence suggests that maintaining an upright posture during labour is not harmful and can support the progress of labour. Midwives should encourage women to adopt comfortable positions and offer guidance based on the baby’s position within the pelvis to optimise rotation and descent.
“Every birth is different, and there is no single best practice for labour. Midwives must be knowledgeable and willing to assist women in trying various birth positions, utilising aids such as birth balls, peanut balls, and rebozos.” (Gupta J.K., Nikodem C., 2000)
The use of herbal supplements, such as evening primrose oil, black haw, black and blue cohosh, and red raspberry leaves, has been explored for cervical ripening and labour induction. However, the evidence supporting their effectiveness is limited, primarily based on traditional use and anecdotal reports. The risks and benefits of these supplements remain uncertain, and further research is needed to evaluate their role in labour induction.
Castor Oil, Hot Baths, and Enemas
Castor oil, hot baths, and enemas have been recommended as nonpharmacologic methods for cervical ripening or labour induction. However, the mechanisms of action for these methods are not well understood, and there is currently no evidence to support their efficacy.
Sexual intercourse is commonly suggested to promote labour initiation. Stimulation of the breasts and nipples during sexual relations can release oxytocin, while penetration stimulates the lower uterine segment, leading to the release of prostaglandins. However, the evidence supporting sexual intercourse as a method of labour induction is limited, and further research is needed to establish its effectiveness.
Breast massage and nipple stimulation have been shown to facilitate the release of oxytocin, which can promote uterine contractions. However, the evidence supporting breast stimulation as a viable method of labour induction is lacking, with poorly designed studies providing inconclusive results.
Acupuncture and Transcutaneous Nerve Stimulation (TENS)
Acupuncture and TENS are alternative approaches that may stimulate the release of prostaglandins and oxytocin, supporting the induction of labour. However, the current evidence for these methods is limited by poorly designed studies, and further research is necessary to evaluate their efficacy.
Tips for a Successful Membrane Sweeping Procedure: Improving Labour Outcomes
Based on the analysis of the reference articles, here are some tips to improve the success rate and outcomes of membrane sweeping:
- Consider the Timing: Membrane sweeping is usually performed at 40 weeks or more of gestation. Accurate assessment of gestational age using first-trimester ultrasound and measurements such as crown-rump length is important to maximise its effectiveness.
- Assess the Cervical Readiness: Before performing membrane sweeping, it is crucial to evaluate the cervical readiness by assessing the Bishop score. Factors such as cervical dilation, effacement, consistency, position, and station are taken into account. A higher Bishop score indicates a more favourable cervix for membrane sweeping.
- Inform and Educate the Patient: Prior to performing membrane sweeping, it is essential to inform and educate the patient about the procedure, its purpose, and potential benefits and risks. This helps the patient make an informed decision and reduces anxiety or fear associated with the procedure.
- Obtain Informed Consent: Informed consent should be obtained from the patient before conducting membrane sweeping. This ensures that the patient understands the procedure, its potential outcomes, and any associated risks. It also demonstrates respect for the patient’s autonomy.
- Use Proper Technique and Sterile Equipment: When performing membrane sweeping, clinicians should adhere to proper technique and use sterile equipment to minimise the risk of infection. This includes wearing gloves, using sterile lubricant, and maintaining aseptic conditions throughout the procedure.
- Consider Pain Management: Membrane sweeping can cause discomfort or pain for some patients. It is important to consider pain management options, such as providing analgesia or offering relaxation techniques, to enhance patient comfort during the procedure.
- Monitor for Complications: Although membrane sweeping is generally safe, it is important to monitor for any potential complications. This includes observing for signs of postpartum haemorrhage, infection, or other adverse events. Prompt intervention should be initiated if any complications arise.
- Supportive Care and Counselling: During and after the membrane sweeping procedure, providing supportive care and counselling to the patient is crucial. This includes answering any questions or concerns the patient may have, discussing the progress of labour, and ensuring emotional support throughout the process.
- Encourage Positional Changes: Positional changes can play a significant role in promoting optimal fetal positioning and rotation. Encourage the labouring woman to try various birth positions, such as upright positions, all-fours, or side-lying, to facilitate the descent of the baby through the pelvis. This can help optimise the outcome of the membrane sweeping procedure.
- Utilise Birth Aids: The use of birth aids, such as birth balls, peanut balls, or rebozos, can provide additional support during labour and enhance the effectiveness of membrane sweeping. These aids can help improve comfort, promote relaxation, and encourage optimal fetal positioning.
- Collaborate with the Multidisciplinary Team: Effective collaboration with the multidisciplinary team, including obstetricians, midwives, and other healthcare professionals, is essential for a successful membrane sweeping procedure. This ensures comprehensive care and facilitates prompt intervention if complications arise.
- Continual Evaluation and Research: Continual evaluation and research are necessary to further enhance the knowledge and understanding of membrane sweeping. This includes conducting larger controlled studies to compare the benefits of membrane sweeping with other methods of labour induction and investigating its effectiveness in high-risk populations.
Patients’ Experience with Membrane Sweeping
While there is limited research on maternal satisfaction with membrane sweeping, available evidence suggests that the majority of participants in studies reported a positive experience. However, it is important to note that very few studies have explored maternal satisfaction or pain as outcomes. More research is needed to better understand pregnant individuals’ views on membrane sweeping and the factors that contribute to their satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the procedure.
A systematic review of qualitative evidence on women’s experiences of membrane sweeping revealed a gap in the literature. One study highlighted that informed consent may not always be obtained before performing the procedure. This finding underscores the need for further qualitative research to inform midwifery practice and ensure that women are adequately informed about membrane sweeping.
Conclusion – Making an Informed Decision about Membrane Sweeping for Inducing Labour
In recent years, there has been a rise in the rates of formal induction of labour. As a result, membrane sweeping has become a routine practice to reduce the need for induction. However, the existing literature on membrane sweeping lacks comprehensive evidence regarding women’s information needs, decision-making, and experiences. This gap raises concerns about the lack of informed decision-making surrounding this procedure.
When deciding whether to undergo a membrane sweep, it is essential to consider personal preferences and consult with a healthcare provider. Each woman’s birthing journey is unique, and discussions with the healthcare team can help determine the best course of action based on individual circumstances, desires, and medical considerations.
Membrane sweeping is a procedure that aims to stimulate labour by gently sweeping a finger around the cervix. While its effectiveness is debated, it remains an option for women approaching their due dates who wish to avoid hospital induction of labour. However, it is important to consider individual preferences and circumstances, as well as explore alternatives and make informed decisions. In the end, the goal is to support women in achieving a safe and positive birthing experience.